Theology of Guilt and Grandad
Being a grandparent has its advantages over being a parent. But after making thousands of mistakes as a parent, it turns out that being a grandparent doesn't make one immune to mistakes. We set up a mini-basketball goal and had a mini-basketball; one of the twins had asked to play basketball. Once we started, the other one wanted the ball also. When the ball rolled away and the first twin went after it, the second one dove on top of her aggressively getting the ball and hurt her in the process. While Daddy dealt with the injury, I talked with the aggressor. She reached that point where you can see that tears are coming soon; it's easy to get a child to feel badly about her behavior. And I realized that I was actually trying to make her feel guilty. That brought to mind what Darlene told our son by marraige years ago, "We raised your wife on guilt." I decided to stop the guilt approach, so I said, "I know you didn't want to hurt your sister. You wanted to get the ball, didn't you?" And it was okay.
But there is a question here. Is it good for a kid to learn and experience guilt or would it be better if adults stuck to talking about behavior? This is not only a question for people of faith and churchgoing people, but for everyone. Unbelievers can and do use guilt just as quickly and easily. And the question has wider application than for parents and grandparents. Is guilt a useful tool to use in calling for change in a person's life? When an evangelist (any person of faith who speaks the News!) seeks to bring about change, is it important and/or necessary to lead a person to feel guilty? It's certainly true that the News declares not only that God is merciful but also that He is just. As one of my teachers said, "Mercy and justice are two sides of the same coin." Much evangelism has attempted to lead people to feel the guilt of Adam, the guilt of society and personal guilt - then to lead them to change, using guilt as a motivation for the change.
Is this necessary or even useful? Do we want new church members who are "raised on guilt" or people who have made thoughtful changes based on their recognition of what pleases God and is good? And do parents want kids who respond to guilt rather than to goodness and valued behavior? Jude does say in verse 23 that in extreme cases even fear is to be used to bring about change. But Paul in his personal life seems to value appreciation of Christ rather than any other motive.
I confess that in my old age I am more comfortable with goodness and sticking with behavior change based on knowing what the Lord wants or what others want rather than guilt. There is work here for the Biblical theologian. And it's important not only for the church that wants to fish for and land the best new members possible, but also for parents and grandparents who want children to grow up with good emotional health.
And even if I do use guilt from time to time, I'm going to do it with as much gentleness as I can muster. Have a happy day.
But there is a question here. Is it good for a kid to learn and experience guilt or would it be better if adults stuck to talking about behavior? This is not only a question for people of faith and churchgoing people, but for everyone. Unbelievers can and do use guilt just as quickly and easily. And the question has wider application than for parents and grandparents. Is guilt a useful tool to use in calling for change in a person's life? When an evangelist (any person of faith who speaks the News!) seeks to bring about change, is it important and/or necessary to lead a person to feel guilty? It's certainly true that the News declares not only that God is merciful but also that He is just. As one of my teachers said, "Mercy and justice are two sides of the same coin." Much evangelism has attempted to lead people to feel the guilt of Adam, the guilt of society and personal guilt - then to lead them to change, using guilt as a motivation for the change.
Is this necessary or even useful? Do we want new church members who are "raised on guilt" or people who have made thoughtful changes based on their recognition of what pleases God and is good? And do parents want kids who respond to guilt rather than to goodness and valued behavior? Jude does say in verse 23 that in extreme cases even fear is to be used to bring about change. But Paul in his personal life seems to value appreciation of Christ rather than any other motive.
I confess that in my old age I am more comfortable with goodness and sticking with behavior change based on knowing what the Lord wants or what others want rather than guilt. There is work here for the Biblical theologian. And it's important not only for the church that wants to fish for and land the best new members possible, but also for parents and grandparents who want children to grow up with good emotional health.
And even if I do use guilt from time to time, I'm going to do it with as much gentleness as I can muster. Have a happy day.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home